![\"VoyF9v\"](\"https:\/\/voynichportal.com\/wp-content\/uploads\/2013\/07\/VoyF9v.jpg\")
<\/a>Description<\/strong><\/p>\nThere is significant controversy (and consternation) over the identities of most of the Voynich plants. The illustrator was reasonably good on details, but short on artistic skills. That’s not to say the drawings are bad\u2014they are better than many of the herbal-style drawings of the time\u2014but they don’t yield their secrets easily, even after centuries of study.<\/p>\n
One plant that has escaped most of the controversy is the flower on Folio 9v. I haven’t searched the Web extensively for plant IDs for this page, but the few that I’ve seen all state that this is probably Viola tricolor<\/em>. I readily agree that it looks like a viola and V. tricolor, <\/em>a common wildflower, should certainly be considered, but I don’t think we can assume it’s V. tricolor<\/em> without considering other possibilities.<\/p>\n Alternative IDs<\/strong><\/p>\n Despite its promising characteristics, Plant 9v probably isn’t V. arvensis<\/em>. In real life it tends to be a bit squatter than this botanical drawing, which is stretched out to show details, and it is more often white than blue. But the key difference is the shape of the flowers. The shape and proportion of the petals varies from one species of viola to the next and V. arvensis<\/em> flowers have a double pair at the top and a broader tongue-shaped petal at the bottom. Plant 9v, in contrast, has three at the top, rather than four.<\/p>\n The Corsican violet (V. corsica<\/em>) and Viola dubyana<\/em> both have many characteristics in common with V. arvensis<\/em> and their colors range from violet-blue to a light purple. Due to the color, both these species match 9v a little more closely than V. arvensis<\/em> but, once again, the shape of the flowers is wrong.<\/p>\n Odd Anomalies<\/strong><\/p>\n But wait a moment.. there’s a mystery in the making. Viola tricolor<\/em> doesn’t match either, even through the leaf shapes, the spacing of the leaves, the roots, and the color are a good match. As with the previous flowers, there are two pairs of petals above and a broader one below. Even an extensive search of other viola species fails to turn up an example that matches all the characteristics of the VM plant\u2014the leaf shapes, growth habit and flower shape\/colors.<\/p>\n Sorting out the anomaly.<\/strong><\/em> Could it be that the flowers on Plant 9v were drawn upside-down? If they are reversed, they would be a good match for any of the above species. This little detail, which I haven’t seen mentioned anywhere else on the Web, surprised me until I thought about it for a few moments. I’d love to believe there is some mystery message in the orientation of the flowers but…<\/p>\n<\/a>There is a field pansy called Viola arvensis<\/em> that matches Plant 9v quite well. It is broadly distributed in Europe and North America and has leaves similar to Plant 9v. Many violas have rounded or heart-shaped leaves that don’t match the VM drawing at all, but V.<\/em> arvensis<\/em> has a mix of lanceolate and spidery palmate leaves very much like Plant 9v. V. arvensis<\/em> is often white and yellow or light blue and yellow, but some variations lean toward violet-blue with yellow. Like Plant 9v, V. arvensis<\/em> branches lightly and has leaves alternating up the stem at some distance\u2014an important detail since many violas have basal whorls and tend not to branch.<\/p>\n<\/a>Before offering an explanation for this anatomical curiosity, it’s worth noting that there is text hidden behind the blue ink in one of the blossoms. I did some Photoshop adjustments to see if the obscured text could be seen more readily and I think I can make out the letter p on the two lower petals (at least) and what appears to be “por” on the upper one. I’ve noticed annotations on other plants, the letter “g”<\/a> on a leaf that was painted green and the letters “r o t” (German for red) on the unpainted stem of plant 4r. If this says “por” then it may mean purple (or violet) as por<\/em> is an abbreviation for purple in several languages.<\/p>\n